Research paper · November 2026
Where an Industry Keeps Its Memory
Abstract
When a shock removes part of an industry from a place, does the industry grow back to where it was? Three answers compete. Locational fundamentals predict full regrowth. Agglomeration predicts that the loss persists because the stock of firms, workers and suppliers is itself the advantage. Institutional commitments predict that whatever is written down at the time of the shock governs what follows. This paper borrows a framing from deer antler biology. An injury to one season's antler can reappear at the same site on later antlers, grown after the injured one was shed. The question here is which of three memory stores carries the regrowth of regional industry. Using U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics QCEW private employment for metropolitan areas by NAICS sector, 2001 to 2025, and the Davis and Weinstein (2002) specification, the pooled slope of post-shock growth on shock-period growth is -0.26 (s.e. 0.03; 2,947 cells) nine years after the 2008 shock and -0.09 (s.e. 0.03; 2,896 cells) five years after the 2020 shock. The 2020 sign reverses when endpoints are two-year averages, so that estimate is provisional, and the standard errors assume independent cells. Placebo slopes are positive (+0.13 and +0.15), so the 2008 result is not generic mean reversion. Full regrowth is rejected for the 2008 episode, where roughly three quarters of the relative loss from 2007 to 2010 persisted to 2019. Solving a geometric pull model for each episode gives implied rates of 3.3 percent a year for 2008 and 1.8 percent for 2020. Each rate is fitted to a single slope and is a summary, not a test. The paper closes with a forecast of 2,896 cell-level probabilities for the 2026 annual averages, written on 16 September 2026 using annual data through 2025, hashed (SHA-256) and published with scoring rules fixed in advance. The author had also seen first-quarter 2026 county data, which were not used in the model.
Cite
Abhay Chakra Sadineni (2026). Where an Industry Keeps Its Memory. Research paper. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24210923 https://www.abhaychakra.com/papers/where-an-industry-keeps-its-memory/